Skip to main navigation
Home
  • About
    • About FAIR
      • Mission, Vision, Values
      • Our Impact
      • Career Opportunities
      • Contact Us
      • Financials
    • Meet The Team
      • Meet the President
      • FAIR Staff
      • Board of Directors
      • Immigration Reform Law Institute
  • Learn
    • Key Issues
      • Illegal Immigration
      • Border Security
      • Sanctuary Policies
    • All Topics
      • Amnesty
      • Legal Immigration
      • National Security
      • Publications & Resources
      • Public Policy
      • Societal Impact
      • Workforce & Economy
      • Population & Environment
  • News
    • FAIR Take
      • Presidential Administration
      • Federal Legislation
      • State & Local Policy
    • FAIR Media
      • Blog
      • Videos
      • Podcasts
      • Newsletters
      • Published Opinion
      • Press Releases
    • Recent News
      border wall, road barricade
      February 11, 2022

      Handful of House Republicans Unveil a New Amnesty Bill

      USCIS
      February 11, 2022

      New USCIS Mission Statement Shows that its Leadership Misunderstands the Assignment

  • Blog
  • Get Involved
    • Take Action
      • Activist Resources
      • How to Report Illegal Aliens
      • Join Our Activist Network
    • Give
      • Donate
      • Planned Giving
      • Other Ways to Support FAIR
  • Contact
    • Contact
      • Career Opportunities
      • Contact Us
    • Pressroom
      • Media Inquiries
      • Past Appearances
      • Press Kits
      • Our Spokespeople
  • Donate
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
Text Resize
  • 100%
  • LG
  • XL
  • XXL
Menu

Breadcrumb

  1. Home
  2. Blog
  3. No, Increased Remittances And Amnesty Will Not Stop Mass Illegal Immigration

No, Increased Remittances And Amnesty Will Not Stop Mass Illegal Immigration

SHARES

Share This Article:

money flying in the sky
Picture of Pawel Styrna
Pawel Styrna
Senior Researcher

The pro-mass-migration, pro-amnesty lobby will enthusiastically employ any argument – no matter how weak or baseless – to justify its agenda. A case in point is Jean Guerrero’s recent column in The Los Angeles Times, in which she asserts that granting illegal aliens amnesty while increasing remittances, and making it easier to send them, will somehow “stop immigration.” Ms. Guerrero’s article is riddled with numerous other problems as well and serves as a window into the flawed assumptions and logic of the radical pro-mass-migration crowd.

The author pitches more remittances – coupled with a “pathway to citizenship” (amnesty) – as a solution far superior to U.S. and international investments in Latin America, which she condemns as the “primary drivers of displacement for Black and Indigenous people — concentrating wealth among local elites and foreign investors.” Her reasoning is that illegal aliens from the Northern Triangle send home so much money in remittances that any promised investments pale in comparison: “the Biden administration pledged $4 billion over four years to Central America. Compare that with $11.4 billion in remittances received just by Guatemalans in 2020 alone. That’s equivalent to 15% of Guatemala’s GDP.”

Although that may be true, it fails to ask whether being dependent on remittances and exporting illegal migrant laborers is an optimal economic development solution to get a country out of poverty and foreign dependency. In fact, by stimulating consumption, it may actually perpetuate those problems in the long run while simultaneously reducing popular pressure on bad governments that keep their countries mired in corruption, crime, and poverty.

While the remittance amounts sent to Central America cited by Ms. Guerrero are indeed substantial, it also translates into large sums of money leaving the U.S. economy. A 2019 FAIR study, which calculated that the U.S. loses $150 billion in remittances each year, explained that “[r]ather than being used to purchase goods and services in the United States, the majority of remittance monies go directly into the pockets of foreign businesses” or governments. As such, it obviously “no longer generates any tax revenue that can be used to pay for public services” here in the U.S. Sadly, the American side of the equation is often left out in discussions of remittances.

Similarly, when The Los Angeles Times columnist touts amnesty, arguing that it “would dramatically boost immigrant earnings, while allowing them to visit loved ones south of the border — lessening the pressure for family reunification in the U.S.,” she forgets that these boosted earnings would come at the expense of native-born American workers and immigrants who migrated the right way. From the history of the misguided 1986 amnesty, we know that mass amnesty actually encourages more illegal immigration given that the illegal alien population has grown at least fivefold between the late 1980s and now. And while remittances may encourage some foreign nationals to remain home, they certainly also convince many to attempt to enter the U.S. illegally to get their own piece of the action. In 2021, for instance, remittances to Latin America and the Caribbean region increased by 25 percent from the previous year, reaching $131 billion (and they are estimated to grow by 9 percent this year), yet illegal migration into the U.S. continues to skyrocket.  

Ms. Guerrero makes one valid point, however. She quotes with approval one Honduran activist asking “[w]hy does nobody ever talk about the right we have to stay [in our home country]?” In fact, FAIR has been emphasizing for decades that a long-term solution to poverty throughout the world is not mass migration but policies in migrant-exporting nations that would make the locals want to remain in their homelands. However, the “right to stay” is undermined by the combination of open borders, amnesty, and dependence on remittances embraced by Ms. Guerrero and many other advocates of mass migration.

Tags

remittances
illegal immigration
Amnesty
media

Share This Article:

< Previous Article Northern Mexico State Steps Up to Turn Back U.S.-Bound Migrants
Next Article > Hawaii Shoplifters Targeted by Homeland Security Investigations

Related Content

Massachusetts driver's license ballot
June 24, 2022

Massachusetts Ballot Petition Aims to Stop Driver's Licenses for Illegal Aliens

Virginia Governor Youngkin black student education
June 24, 2022

In Virginia, Gov. Youngkin’s Budget Helps Black American Students At The Expense of Illegal Aliens

workers standing in diagonal line
June 21, 2022

Mass Immigration Won’t Stimulate Post-Covid Recovery: Debunking America-Last Economic Myths

Tweets

June 29, 2022 | 4:20PM

Texas tractor-trailer migrant deaths: Two Mexican nationals living in US illegally hit with weapons charges https://t.co/Ds4GtRD2Da

@FAIRImmigration
June 29, 2022 | 3:00PM

By failing to secure the border, the Biden administration is making everyone less safe. https://t.co/aCkLObVyqc

@FAIRImmigration

© Copyright 2022 Federation for American Immigration Reform, All Rights Reserved
25 Massachusetts Ave. NW Ste. 330, Washington, DC 20001
Phone: (202) 328-7004   Fax: 202.387.3447

 

Stay Connected

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest

Footer

  • Home
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • About
    • About FAIR
      • Mission, Vision, Values
      • Our Impact
      • Career Opportunities
      • Contact Us
      • Financials
    • Meet The Team
      • Meet the President
      • FAIR Staff
      • Board of Directors
      • Immigration Reform Law Institute
  • Learn
    • Key Issues
      • Illegal Immigration
      • Border Security
      • Sanctuary Policies
    • All Topics
      • Amnesty
      • Legal Immigration
      • National Security
      • Publications & Resources
      • Public Policy
      • Societal Impact
      • Workforce & Economy
      • Population & Environment
  • News
    • FAIR Take
      • Presidential Administration
      • Federal Legislation
      • State & Local Policy
    • FAIR Media
      • Blog
      • Videos
      • Podcasts
      • Newsletters
      • Published Opinion
      • Press Releases
    • Recent News
  • Blog
  • Get Involved
    • Take Action
      • Activist Resources
      • How to Report Illegal Aliens
      • Join Our Activist Network
    • Give
      • Donate
      • Planned Giving
      • Other Ways to Support FAIR
  • Contact
    • Contact
      • Career Opportunities
      • Contact Us
    • Pressroom
      • Media Inquiries
      • Past Appearances
      • Press Kits
      • Our Spokespeople
  • Donate