Skip to main navigation
Home
  • About
    • About FAIR
      • Mission, Vision, Values
      • Our Impact
      • Career Opportunities
      • Contact Us
      • Financials
    • Meet The Team
      • Meet the President
      • FAIR Staff
      • Board of Directors
      • Immigration Reform Law Institute
  • Learn
    • Key Issues
      • Illegal Immigration
      • Border Security
      • Sanctuary Policies
    • All Topics
      • Amnesty
      • Legal Immigration
      • National Security
      • Publications & Resources
      • Public Policy
      • Societal Impact
      • Workforce & Economy
      • Population & Environment
  • News
    • FAIR Take
      • Presidential Administration
      • Federal Legislation
      • State & Local Policy
    • FAIR Media
      • Blog
      • Videos
      • Podcasts
      • Newsletters
      • Published Opinion
      • Press Releases
    • Recent News
      border wall, road barricade
      February 11, 2022

      Handful of House Republicans Unveil a New Amnesty Bill

      USCIS
      February 11, 2022

      New USCIS Mission Statement Shows that its Leadership Misunderstands the Assignment

  • Blog
  • Get Involved
    • Take Action
      • Activist Resources
      • How to Report Illegal Aliens
      • Join Our Activist Network
    • Give
      • Donate
      • Planned Giving
      • Other Ways to Support FAIR
  • Contact
    • Contact
      • Career Opportunities
      • Contact Us
    • Pressroom
      • Media Inquiries
      • Past Appearances
      • Press Kits
      • Our Spokespeople
  • Donate
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
Text Resize
  • 100%
  • LG
  • XL
  • XXL
Menu

Breadcrumb

  1. Home
  2. The (Il)Logic of Open-Border Libertarians

The (Il)Logic of Open-Border Libertarians

Broken Chain

May 2014 | Read the Full Report (PDF)


Introduction

Libertarianism has gained a more prominent position within American political discourse in recent years, in large part because younger voters are increasingly rejecting the politics of both major parties and are looking for alternatives. As libertarianism becomes a broader political movement, self-identified libertarians are attempting to define the core philosophy or set of principles that characterizes that movement. Much like the Tea Party, which is working to forge its identity as an organized political party, libertarianism is experiencing the growing pains that go along with transforming a limited movement into an effective political force.

There is much debate about what are the fundamental principles of libertarianism and how those principles apply to immigration policy. Libertarian proponents of the free movement of people across borders, most notably those employed by the Cato Institute and the Reason Foundation, portray their embrace of open borders as an immutable ideological component of the libertarian cause, the only position a true libertarian can take. However, even a cursory reading on the issue reveals that many scholars who hold positions of influence within the libertarian movement have not embraced mass immigration as a practical objective, and, in fact, view it as a means to a more powerful and intrusive central government. 

Big-business interests have a large stake in the outcome of the debate over immigration, and they have spent much money supporting libertarian “think-tanks” that espouse an open-border policy for the United States. By all appearances, this has very little to do with any principled commitment to libertarian principles, but is a way to provide ideological cover for multi-national corporations who lobby for the passage of legislation that will undermine the standing of American workers and force taxpayers to subsidize the costs of a cheaper foreign labor force. An open border, or at least a more open border, would allow corporations to further consolidate their hold on the U.S. economy, while the middle class would lose more of its economic and political power.

FAIR does not promote or denigrate libertarianism, but we do wish to have an honest debate about immigration policy and corresponding political solutions. One does not have to be a libertarian to see that certain commentators who claim to speak on behalf of the movement are using disingenuous and sometimes dishonest arguments to present their position as the libertarian position on immigration.

Related Content

Massachusetts driver's license ballot
June 24, 2022

Massachusetts Ballot Petition Aims to Stop Driver's Licenses for Illegal Aliens

Virginia Governor Youngkin black student education
June 24, 2022

In Virginia, Gov. Youngkin’s Budget Helps Black American Students At The Expense of Illegal Aliens

Homeland Security Brand
June 17, 2022

Proposed FY2023 DHS Spending Bill Fails to Address Border Crisis

Immigration Term

Metropolitan Statistical Area (MSA)

The U.S. Office of Management and Budget defines a MSA as a core area with at least 50,000 residents and bordering communities which are socially and economically integrated with the central city. Larger metropolitan areas are termed Primary MSAs, or PMSAs. Metropolitan areas made up of more than one PMSA and with with one million or more residents may be recognized as Consolidated Metropolitan Statistical Areas (CMSAs). The county-based alternative for the New England states is known as New England County Metropolitan Areas (NECMAs).

Tweets

July 4, 2022 | 9:18AM

Poll: Most Say lllegal Immigration Getting ‘Worse,’ Will Be ‘Important’ Issue in Midterms via @BreitbartNews https://t.co/jBiyvrvQm6

@FAIRImmigration
July 4, 2022 | 8:27AM

North Carolina Migrant Shelter Quietly Opens after HHS Denies Plan to Congress via @JudicialWatch https://t.co/ar1pTLeLu5

@FAIRImmigration

© Copyright 2022 Federation for American Immigration Reform, All Rights Reserved
25 Massachusetts Ave. NW Ste. 330, Washington, DC 20001
Phone: (202) 328-7004   Fax: 202.387.3447

 

Stay Connected

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest

Footer

  • Home
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • About
    • About FAIR
      • Mission, Vision, Values
      • Our Impact
      • Career Opportunities
      • Contact Us
      • Financials
    • Meet The Team
      • Meet the President
      • FAIR Staff
      • Board of Directors
      • Immigration Reform Law Institute
  • Learn
    • Key Issues
      • Illegal Immigration
      • Border Security
      • Sanctuary Policies
    • All Topics
      • Amnesty
      • Legal Immigration
      • National Security
      • Publications & Resources
      • Public Policy
      • Societal Impact
      • Workforce & Economy
      • Population & Environment
  • News
    • FAIR Take
      • Presidential Administration
      • Federal Legislation
      • State & Local Policy
    • FAIR Media
      • Blog
      • Videos
      • Podcasts
      • Newsletters
      • Published Opinion
      • Press Releases
    • Recent News
  • Blog
  • Get Involved
    • Take Action
      • Activist Resources
      • How to Report Illegal Aliens
      • Join Our Activist Network
    • Give
      • Donate
      • Planned Giving
      • Other Ways to Support FAIR
  • Contact
    • Contact
      • Career Opportunities
      • Contact Us
    • Pressroom
      • Media Inquiries
      • Past Appearances
      • Press Kits
      • Our Spokespeople
  • Donate