Big Texas ICE Raids Have Little Impact
A raid at a Dallas-area technology companynetted nearly 300 illegal aliens last week, immigration agents’ largest haul ina decade. But after a couple of days of attention-grabbing headlines and filmfootage, the long-term impact of the operation is unclear.
Of the 280 arrested CVE Technology Group workers, hailing from 15 countries, 174 were released on their own recognizance.
U.S. Immigration andCustoms Enforcement (ICE) said overcrowding at detention facilitiesnecessitated the release. The freed workers were given notices to appearbefore a federal immigration judge at some future date (wink, wink).
ICE has been especially busy in North Texas. In 2017, the most recent year with complete data, Dallas ICE agents arrested nearly 17,000 people, the most in the United States. The region extends south to Waco and west to Lubbock.
While touting workplace raids as crucial to breaking up criminal enterprises, ICE rarely discloses the names of those arrested, making it difficult to know what actually becomes of their cases. The Center for Immigration Studies is suing ICE for slow-walking or blocking the release of arrest and deportation data.
If an earlier large-scale bust at anotherDallas area company is an indication, CVE will be back to business as usual.
Last August, ICE hauled away 160 illegal aliens working at Load Trail, a trailer manufacturer. That raid came four years after the company was fined $445,000 for employing 179 illegal laborers.
Thoughillegal aliens constituted roughly a third of Load Trail’s workforce, thecompany was making trailers two days after the latest ICE action, with some ofthe same apprehended workers back on the assembly line.
Company attorney Gene Besen said people who were arrested would remain on the job unless they could not show two forms of ID upon their return. (Counterfeit IDs and document fraud, anyone?)
Although Load Trail is under a court order to use the federal E-Verify employee-screening system, a company insider told WFAA News there was a workaround.
“I would take [applicant] information andenter it into E-Verify. If it kicked it back, then they would have me hire themunder their other company that was not under court order to E-Verify,” theinformant said.
Dallas immigration attorney Eric Puente called ICE’s Texas raids “a sensational way of reaching a certain objective. I don’t know what the government’s objective is.”
Financial penalties, perhaps? The standard fine for hiring illegal aliens who constitute 30 to 39 percent of a company is $2,411 per conviction on a first offense.
If that seems like a serious disincentivefor having illegal aliens on the payroll, the repeat-offending Load Trail suggestsit’s not nearly punitive enough. Clearly, some firms merely consider such finesto be the cost of employing low-wage migrants, and worth risking periodic ICEroundups.
A week after the raid at CVE, neither ICE nor the U.S. Attorney’s Office has said what, if any, charges or might be brought against company employees or executives responsible for hiring unauthorized workers. Also no word on charges stemming from ICE’s second raid of Load Trail eight months ago (though current and former employees are suing the company for failing to pay required overtime).